Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Top 5 unreleased songs, go!

protopostmodern
May 10, 2011 02:17PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
i dont believe milk song has ever been played live.

edit #1: if so, would someone point me to a date?

edit #2: besides sir arnes treasure



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 05/10/2011 02:19PM by protopostmodern.
Reply Quote
Caliclimber
May 10, 2011 03:03PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Why besides Sir Arne's Treasure? It was played live there which legitimates it for discussion.
Reply Quote
dollabill
May 10, 2011 03:16PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
I don't want to take away from the Milk Song discussion, but I really like their cover of Boys are Back in Town with the R Kelly remix to ignition ending. In addition to everything that's been named before, obviously.


I've got big plans. ◊ Talking Blanket ◊ Yay, Butts! LOL!
Reply Quote
protopostmodern
May 10, 2011 03:36PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
i suppose, but (i cannot remember the source, i'll look for it) john was not into the bootleg of sir arne's treasure. if this is the only recording we have of it, it is not legitimate.
Reply Quote
Wild Creature
May 10, 2011 03:39PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Quote
protopostmodern
i suppose, but (i cannot remember the source, i'll look for it) john was not into the bootleg of sir arne's treasure. if this is the only recording we have of it, it is not legitimate.

i don't remember hearing this about JD. I'd be interested in the source.


The first thing that distinguishes a writer is that he is most alive when alone. - Martin Amis
Reply Quote
Caliclimber
May 10, 2011 03:44PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Quote
protopostmodern
i suppose, but (i cannot remember the source, i'll look for it) john was not into the bootleg of sir arne's treasure. if this is the only recording we have of it, it is not legitimate.

I completely disagree. No more argument from me.
Reply Quote
protopostmodern
May 10, 2011 03:45PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
okay, if i ever did find JD's official word on it, i cannot find it in the 20 minutes between now and that post. i did however find this:

"Except that it's 2011, which means that of course someone bootlegged the entire concert and posted it online. Here it is via the Indie Rock Snob, caveat pending--this may well not be the state Darnielle would prefer anybody to hear it in."

italics added for emphasis.
Reply Quote
protopostmodern
May 10, 2011 03:45PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Quote
Caliclimber
Quote
protopostmodern
i suppose, but (i cannot remember the source, i'll look for it) john was not into the bootleg of sir arne's treasure. if this is the only recording we have of it, it is not legitimate.

I completely disagree. No more argument from me.

so if john said, no please don't download this bootleg, you would do it anyway?

if john says no then that makes it illegitimate. which is not cool as far as creator consent and rights go.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 05/10/2011 03:46PM by protopostmodern.
Reply Quote
Wild Creature
May 10, 2011 03:50PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
JD has said on this forum on a few occasions that anything live is open game. i know of only one exception to this, in which JD expressly named a song he did not want traded, or even played, or even tab'd, and milk song was not it. plus, he subsequently played that song live, again, which confused me. still, i don't trade it, mention it on lists, etc. then again, i don't really love the song anyways, so it's kind of easy for me. but there is no other song i know of where trading live versions is a no-no. i'm happy to be corrected on the point, I just don't know of one.

the two cents of me.


The first thing that distinguishes a writer is that he is most alive when alone. - Martin Amis



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 05/10/2011 03:51PM by Wild Creature.
Reply Quote
protopostmodern
May 10, 2011 03:54PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
and that makes sense. but it seems like the nature of this performance makes it weird territory. to each their own. if they wanna take the risk, that's cool. i'll sleep, obviously, as it's only music.
Reply Quote
Wild Creature
May 10, 2011 03:59PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
we frighten ourselves, unnecessarily.


The first thing that distinguishes a writer is that he is most alive when alone. - Martin Amis



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 05/10/2011 04:00PM by Wild Creature.
Reply Quote
Caliclimber
May 10, 2011 04:16PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Protopostmodern I think you're confusing two issues. JD has said many times he doesn't like live recordings. That's why he would never release a live album. He feels a live recording can never replicate the live experience. In the case of Sir Arne that is doubly true since it was meant to accompany the film. At the same time he's also made it clear he knows his fans like his live recordings and he has no problem with that. The Sir Arne show was played live and recordings are available. JD has said that legitimizes a show for trading purposes and certainly discussion. We're certainly entitled to our own opinions. Ok, now I'm done. It's all good.
Reply Quote
pabrian
May 10, 2011 04:47PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Quote
SlowWestVulture
Quote
pabrian
15-2
Calcutta

What bootlegs are these from? They aren't on any of the one's I have or have seen, and themountaingoats.net doesn't say.

Thanks!

Oops. I meant 02-75. I'm not sure why I was thinking 15-2 since I've never heard it. Maybe because I have always wanted to hear it.

Calcutta I have on a recording. I'm not certain which one, but as soon as I get home and confirm which one, I'll repost a link.

NYU show from March 1997. This is the first part of the show as it was too long to upload as one. Calcutta is the second song of the set after what has to be one of the earliest live versions of Baboon to start off the set.

[www.mediafire.com]

Part two of the show is here.

[www.mediafire.com]



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 05/10/2011 09:14PM by pabrian.
Reply Quote
jacobfiala
May 10, 2011 04:57PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Letter From A Motel x5
Reply Quote
SlowWestVulture
May 10, 2011 10:08PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Quote
pabrian
Quote
SlowWestVulture
Quote
pabrian
15-2
Calcutta

What bootlegs are these from? They aren't on any of the one's I have or have seen, and themountaingoats.net doesn't say.

Thanks!

Oops. I meant 02-75. I'm not sure why I was thinking 15-2 since I've never heard it. Maybe because I have always wanted to hear it.

Calcutta I have on a recording. I'm not certain which one, but as soon as I get home and confirm which one, I'll repost a link.

NYU show from March 1997. This is the first part of the show as it was too long to upload as one. Calcutta is the second song of the set after what has to be one of the earliest live versions of Baboon to start off the set.

[www.mediafire.com]

Part two of the show is here.

[www.mediafire.com]

Thank you very much! The song (and setlist, for that matter) is great! And so is 02-75, I felt weird not including on my list.


I make videos for the interwebs. Click to taste the insanity.
My band has a Facebook. This is the link.
Reply Quote
EvilEivind
May 11, 2011 06:59AM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
No love for "Counting Song For Bitter Children"? I really like that song, but unfortunately didn't have the room to squeeze it in.


Why's everyone in this thread a f***ing Mountain Goats fan?!

Kirkeby Kritikk • Kvitter
Reply Quote
Gaius Verres
May 11, 2011 09:44AM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Quote
EvilEivind
No love for "Counting Song For Bitter Children"? I really like that song, but unfortunately didn't have the room to squeeze it in.

Yes. It just missed the Top 5 for me.


O curas hominum! O quantum est in rebus inane!
Reply Quote
jeremypaulhenderson
May 11, 2011 12:36PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Standard Bitter Love Song #1
You're in Maya
Steel Smoked Fish
Reply Quote
SlowWestVulture
May 11, 2011 01:40PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Was Steel Smoked Fish really that awesome? Or are you guys just making a WTO-like joke?


I make videos for the interwebs. Click to taste the insanity.
My band has a Facebook. This is the link.
Reply Quote
jeremypaulhenderson
May 11, 2011 03:56PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
I enjoyed it. Great story associated with it + amazing crowed energy = good times.
Reply Quote
mkslider
May 11, 2011 04:22PM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Quote
SlowWestVulture
Was Steel Smoked Fish really that awesome? Or are you guys just making a WTO-like joke?

it was pretty awesome. Of course it would seem less awesome if I could listen to it every day. But it was awesome.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 05/11/2011 04:23PM by mkslider.
Reply Quote
nutopia1213
May 17, 2011 12:06AM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Ethiopians
From TG&Y
You're in Maya
I've Got the Sex
Sign of the Crow

thnx to betamax for doing most of the work for me
Reply Quote
little insect
May 17, 2011 12:25AM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Car Song
Shower
SBLS 5

I would like there to be more car song love, please.


What I spend a lot of my free time doing.
Reply Quote
protopostmodern
May 17, 2011 10:04AM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
although this makes it more than five songs, i'd like to add these to the list:

going to buffalo
etiquette song
going to detroit (or what we have of it)
brandy lets go
like a bullet!

changed last one because i forgot it was released.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 05/17/2011 11:41AM by protopostmodern.
Reply Quote
Johnp
May 17, 2011 10:29AM | Re: Top 5 unreleased songs, go!
Quote
protopostmodern
november love song

= Un Rêve Plus Long Que La Nuit = released on Gold Kiss Gala.
Reply Quote
Page 2 of 3    Pages: Previous123Next
Newer Topic Older Topic
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login

Online Users

Guests: 23
Record Number of Users: 8 on May 22, 2013
Record Number of Guests: 40 on May 24, 2013